If you are being asked whether your company should invest in answer engine optimization, or AEO, you are probably hearing two loud and opposite answers. Vendors say every business needs it now. Skeptics say AI search is overhyped. Neither answer is about your business, and neither gives you anything to take into a budget meeting.
AEO means making sure AI tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, and Google's AI results can find your business, understand it, and recommend it accurately. In our work with clients, the pattern we see is that its value has little to do with company size, budget, or how strong your current SEO is. It depends on your category: how your buyers decide, and whether AI tools have become part of that decision.
Below is the five-factor framework we use to score that. For each factor, you will find why it matters, how to gather the evidence, what a low, middle, and high score look like, and the most common scoring mistake. After the factors, there are worked examples, a guide to reading your total, and a 90-day plan for each result. The framework is a working heuristic, not a validated benchmark, and it is designed to be repeated as your category changes. It is also the logic behind our companion posts, "AEO for SaaS" and "AEO Is Not for Everyone."
Before you score: gather the right evidence
An hour of preparation makes the score far more reliable.
The most common reason this kind of assessment goes wrong is that people score from opinion rather than evidence. Before you start, collect three things.
Your buyers' real questions. Pull the ten questions customers ask most before choosing, from sales call notes, support tickets, chat logs, reviews, and the search queries in Google Search Console. Use their wording, not your marketing language.
AI answers to those questions. Ask each question in at least four AI tools and save the answers. Note how detailed each answer is, which businesses are named, how each one is described, and which sources are cited.
Your team's view of how customers decide. Ask your sales and customer success leads three questions: How long does a typical customer take to decide? How many people are usually involved? What finally tips the decision? Their answers anchor several of the factors below.
Factor 1: Research intensity
How much do your buyers research before they buy?
Why it matters. This is the strongest single predictor of AEO's value. AI tools are best at the work buyers do while researching: comparing options, summarizing reviews, and explaining trade-offs. The more research your buyers do, the more of it is likely moving into those tools. G2's March 2026 survey of 1,076 B2B software buyers found that 51% now start software research with an AI chatbot more often than with Google, and 71% rely on AI chatbots at some point in their research. McKinsey's October 2025 research found that 44% of people who use AI-powered search call it their primary source of insight, ahead of traditional search at 31%.
How to assess it. Look at your sales cycle length, the number of pages a typical buyer views before converting, how often prospects mention comparing you with competitors, and whether customers ask detailed questions before buying. A long, question-heavy journey is a strong signal.
Scoring. Score 5 if buyers routinely compare several options over days or weeks, as in software, financial services, healthcare, education, travel, home improvement, and considered consumer purchases such as electronics or furniture. Score 3 if some buyers research carefully and others decide quickly, as in many mid-priced consumer categories. Score 1 if most buyers decide on price, proximity, or habit with little comparison, such as reordering office supplies or choosing the nearest coffee shop.
Common mistake. Scoring based on how much research your best customers do. Score based on how your typical buyer behaves.
Factor 2: AI answer depth in your category
When people ask AI tools about your category, do they get detailed answers that name businesses?
Why it matters. Research intensity tells you whether buyers could use AI. Answer depth tells you whether AI tools are actually giving them something to act on in your category. A category where AI answers name and compare specific businesses is one where your presence in those answers directly affects who gets considered.
How to assess it. Use the answers you collected. You cannot easily measure how often people ask AI tools about your category, but you can measure what they get when they do. Each tool finds and weighs sources in its own way, so check at least four, and look for patterns rather than relying on any single answer.
Scoring. Score 5 if the answers are detailed, compare specific businesses or products, explain trade-offs, and cite sources. Score 3 if the answers are general, give advice without naming businesses, or name only a few large players. Score 1 if the answers are thin, decline to recommend, or mostly send people elsewhere, such as to a map or a marketplace.
What to note while scoring. Whether competitors are named and you are not. If they are, that gap is already costing you, whatever your total score turns out to be. Also note how you are described when you do appear. An inaccurate or outdated description is a problem in its own right.
Common mistake. Asking questions in your company's language rather than your buyers'. A buyer asks "what's the best tool to track my team's projects," not "which work management platform offers the most robust resource allocation."
Factor 3: Content differentiability
Can a written answer show why you are the better choice?
Why it matters. AI tools recommend businesses for reasons they can find and state. If your advantages are concrete and checkable, an AI answer can repeat them. If they are mostly intangible, an answer has little to say about you beyond your name.
How to assess it. List the three reasons your best customers chose you. For each, ask: could a stranger verify this from public information? Specific features, pricing models, integrations, certifications, guarantees, and measurable results are verifiable. Atmosphere, personal relationships, and "great service" are harder to state in a comparison unless reviews describe them in specific terms.
Scoring. Score 5 if your strengths are specific and checkable, such as "integrates with the three accounting tools our customers use most" or "certified for a particular regulation." Score 3 if some strengths are specific and others are not. Score 1 if you compete mainly on intangibles or on price alone.
Common mistake. Treating a low score here as fixed. This is the one factor you can change directly, by clarifying your positioning and publishing the specific facts behind it. A business that scores 2 today can often score 4 within a quarter.
Factor 4: Decision complexity
How much is riding on the decision, and how many people are involved?
Why it matters. Complex decisions generate more research, more questions, and more people who each want to check the options. Each of those people may consult AI tools separately. Gartner reported in 2026 that 45% of B2B buyers had used generative AI during a recent purchase, mainly to gather information about vendors and products, and 69% said they prefer to validate AI-generated insights with a sales rep. In complex purchases, AI shapes the shortlist and humans confirm it.
How to assess it. Use your sales team's answers. Count the typical number of people involved, look at the average deal size or purchase price, and consider how hard the decision is to reverse.
Scoring. Score 5 for high-stakes, multi-person decisions, such as enterprise software, a financial advisor, a medical procedure, or a major home renovation. Score 3 for moderate decisions, such as a mid-priced appliance or a small-business service. Score 1 for quick, low-risk choices, such as where to have lunch.
Common mistake. Confusing price with complexity. A modest purchase can be complex if it is hard to reverse or involves several people, such as choosing a childcare provider.
Factor 5: AI ecosystem exposure
How many AI systems are already shaping decisions in your category?
Why it matters. Beyond consumer chatbots, AI now shows up in comparison tools, shopping assistants, map and local search features, and agents built into everyday work software. These systems read your website, your listings, and what others say about you, often without leaving a trace in your analytics. Accenture's 2026 Consumer Pulse survey found that 71% of consumers expect generative AI to influence at least half of their spending decisions over the next year.
How to assess it. Look for AI features in the places your buyers already shop: AI summaries on review and marketplace sites, AI shopping assistants from major retailers, AI-generated comparisons in your industry's directories, and AI features inside the work tools your buyers use. Also check your analytics for visits referred by AI tools, which shows whether that traffic has started to arrive.
Scoring. Score 5 if AI tools, agents, or comparison services are clearly active in your category. Score 3 if they are emerging. Score 1 if you see little sign of them.
Why this factor moves fastest. This has changed most for local businesses. BrightLocal's February 2026 survey found that 45% of consumers had used AI tools for local business recommendations, up from 6% a year earlier. A restaurant or trades business that would have scored 1 here a year ago may now score 2 or 3.
The scoring guide
Is AEO worth it for you?
Score your business from 1 to 5 on each factor. Fives are where AEO matters most.
Use the descriptions as anchors and pick the closest match in each row.
| Factor | Score | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3 | 5 | |
| Research intensity | Decided on price, proximity or habit | Mixed | Buyers compare options over days or weeks |
| AI answer depth | Thin answers or redirects | General answers, few names | Detailed, cited answers naming businesses |
| Content differentiation | Intangibles or price only | Partly specific | Specific, checkable strengths |
| Decision complexity | Quick, low-risk | Moderate | High-stakes, several people involved |
| AI ecosystem exposure | Little sign of AI tools | Emerging | AI tools and agents clearly active |
Want this framework scored for you automatically? Take the free AEO Readiness Assessment — the same five-factor logic, six questions, instant results. No email required.
Reading your total
Add the five scores. The total points to a level of priority, not a verdict.
20 to 25: a top strategic priority. Your buyers are deciding in AI tools, and your presence in those answers affects who gets considered. Clarity and reputation in AI answers pay off across every platform.
12 to 19: worth focused investment. AI is part of how some of your buyers decide. Start with the pages and questions that matter most, and track how AI tools describe you over time.
Below 12: focus on fundamentals. Your budget is usually better spent on what drives decisions in your category today. For local businesses, those fundamentals are also what AI tools read, so they double as AEO.
Reading the pattern, not just the total
Two businesses with the same total can need very different plans.
The individual scores often matter more than the sum. A few patterns come up repeatedly.
High research intensity, low AI answer depth. Your buyers research heavily, but AI answers in your category are still thin. This is an early-mover opportunity. The category is likely to fill in, and businesses that are clearly described now are well placed when it does.
High AI answer depth, low content differentiability. AI tools are actively comparing businesses in your category, but there is little specific for them to say about you. This is the most urgent pattern, because competitors with clearer positioning are probably being recommended instead. Start by sharpening and publishing the specific facts behind your strengths.
Low research intensity, high ecosystem exposure. Buyers decide quickly, but AI features are appearing where they shop, such as local search or marketplace assistants. Focus on accurate listings, reviews, and product data rather than long-form content.
High complexity, moderate answer depth. AI shapes early research, but buyers confirm with people. Pair AI visibility with strong proof on your own site and easy access to a knowledgeable person, since that is where these decisions are confirmed.
Four worked examples
Illustrations of how the scoring plays out in different categories.
Is AEO worth it for you?
The same five factors, four very different businesses. Totals range from 24 to 10 out of 25.
These are illustrations of how the scoring plays out in different categories, not measured results.
| Business | Score, 1 to 5 | Total, out of 25 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Research | Answer depth | Differentiation | Complexity | Exposure | ||
| Mid-market software company | 5 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 24 |
| Direct-to-consumer skincare brand | 4 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 17 |
| Regional accounting firm | 3 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 2 | 14 |
| Neighborhood restaurant | 1 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 10 |
Each factor is scored from 1 to 5, so totals run from 5 to 25. Bars show the total on the full 0–25 scale, with a mark at the midpoint.
The software company is a clear priority. Its buyers research for weeks, AI answers compare named vendors, and several people check the shortlist. Its main work is keeping its description accurate and earning mentions in the sources AI tools cite.
The skincare brand sits in the middle with an important gap. Buyers research ingredients and compare products, and AI answers name brands, but its differentiators are not yet specific enough. Publishing clear ingredient information, results, and certifications would likely raise both its score and its visibility.
The accounting firm is also in the middle, for a different reason. Decisions are significant, but AI answers in its local market are still general. It should keep its listings and reviews strong, state its specialties plainly, and recheck in six months.
The restaurant scores below 12, but that does not mean it can ignore AI. For it, "fundamentals" has a specific meaning: an accurate Google Business Profile, current hours, real photos, and a steady flow of recent reviews. Those are exactly what AI tools read when they recommend local businesses, so for a local business, the fundamentals are its AEO.
The question is not whether AI search matters. It is whether it matters where your customers decide.
What to do in the next 90 days, by result
Each score points to a different first step.
If you scored 20 to 25: In the first month, establish a monthly check of how AI tools answer your buyers' top ten questions, and fix any inaccurate facts about your company on your site, profiles, and listings. In the second month, identify the outside sources AI tools cite most for your category and plan how to earn accurate coverage there. In the third month, publish or improve pages that answer the follow-up questions buyers ask, such as comparisons, pricing, and use cases, and add AI-referred visits and branded search to your monthly report.
If you scored 12 to 19: Pick three to five pages tied to your buyers' most important questions and make them clearer and better supported. Make sure your company description is consistent everywhere it appears. Check monthly whether AI tools describe you more accurately or name you more often, and decide at the end of the quarter whether to expand.
If you scored below 12: Focus on the fundamentals buyers and AI tools both rely on: accurate listings, current hours and policies, and a steady flow of genuine reviews. Set a reminder to rescore in six months, since this is the result most likely to change without you doing anything.
The evidence behind the factors
AI in buying decisions
Half of B2B software buyers start research with an AI chatbot. 45% of US consumers have asked AI for a local recommendation.
Business and consumer buyers are moving the same way. Across 16 countries, 71% of consumers expect AI to influence at least half of their spending within a year.
| Finding | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| B2B buyers | ||
| B2B software buyers who start research with an AI chatbot more often than Google | 51% | G2, survey of 1,076 buyers, April 15, 2026 |
| B2B software buyers who rely on AI chatbots at some point in research | 71% | G2, April 15, 2026 |
| B2B buyers who used generative AI in a recent purchase, all categories | 45% | Gartner, 2026 |
| Consumers | ||
| Consumers expecting generative AI to influence at least half of their spending in the next 12 months, 16 countries | 71% | Accenture Consumer Pulse, June 2026 |
| US consumers who used AI tools for a local business recommendation in the past year, 2025 versus 2026 | 6% → 45% | BrightLocal, February 2026 |
G2 surveyed B2B software buyers in March 2026; Accenture surveyed 25,590 consumers in 16 countries; BrightLocal surveyed 1,002 US consumers. The two 71% figures measure different things in different populations. G2 runs a software review site and BrightLocal sells local marketing software.
G2 surveyed B2B software buyers; Accenture surveyed 25,590 consumers in 16 countries; BrightLocal surveyed 1,002 U.S. consumers. G2 runs a software review site and BrightLocal sells local marketing software. All figures are self-reported survey results.
The ledger: what scoring costs and what it gives you
The framework is cheap to run and expensive to skip.
Scoring takes a few hours: gathering your buyers' real questions, running them through several AI tools, and talking honestly with your sales team about how customers decide. What you gain is a defensible answer for leadership, grounded in your own category rather than in vendor claims or headlines. What makes it worth repeating is that every factor except content differentiability can shift within a year, as the local-business change shows.
Four failure modes to watch for
Each one makes the score less useful than it looks.
The first is scoring generously: rating your category the way you would like it to be rather than how buyers actually behave. Ask sales and customer success to score it independently. The second is checking only one AI tool, which can make your category look more or less active than it is. The third is scoring once and forgetting. The fourth is reading a low score as permission to ignore your listings and reviews, which are often what AI tools use to describe you anyway.
Test small, then make it a routine
Validate the score before you commit budget to it.
If your score suggests AEO matters, test it before rebuilding your plan. Pick three to five pages tied to your buyers' top questions, make them clearer and better supported, and check over the following weeks whether AI tools describe you more accurately or name you more often. If they do, extend the work. If they do not, revisit your scores before spending more.
Then write the scoring steps on one page and hand them to a colleague. If they can run the assessment next quarter without you and reach a similar result, the framework is doing its job.
What this likely means over the next 6 to 18 months
Expect scores to rise in more categories, and faster than most teams plan for.
If current trends continue, more categories will likely move up on AI answer depth and ecosystem exposure, as local search already has. That would mean more businesses crossing from "fundamentals" into "focused investment" without changing anything themselves. The safest approach is to treat the score as something to recheck every six months, and to keep the fundamentals, accurate information, strong reviews, and clear positioning, in good shape regardless of where you land.
If you want this framework scored for you, Camino5's free AEO Ready Score uses the same logic in six questions.
How to start today
Collect the ten questions your buyers ask most before choosing, from sales, support, and reviews.
Ask them in at least four AI tools and note how detailed the answers are, which businesses are named, and which sources are cited.
Score your category on the five factors with your sales and customer success leads, separately, then compare.
Write down your total, what it means, and the one action it points to first.
Put a reminder on the calendar to rescore in six months.
AEO is not a yes-or-no question for every business; it is a question about where your customers decide, and the businesses that answer it honestly will spend less and show up more.
Sources
G2, "The Answer Economy: G2's 2026 AI Search Insight Report," April 2026
Gartner, B2B buyer survey on generative AI use, 2026
Accenture, "Talk to my AI agent: The new rules of brand value," Consumer Pulse Research 2026
BrightLocal, local SEO statistics for 2026 (Local Consumer Review Survey, February 2026)